Passion For Life.
Now is the time to draw the line
| Latest News |
|---|
info@passionforlife.org.uk
Send a Postcard!  |
 |
| How MPs voted on mixed embryos |
 |
 |
 |
| Latest | |
| Written by Editor | |
| Tuesday, 20 May 2008 10:20 | |
|
Here is the Hansard link for yesterdays' debate in the House of Commons on the HFE bill.
This is the division list (voting record) of how MPs voted on Edward Leigh MPs amendment to prohibit mixing animal/human hybrids. The amendment was lost by 160 votes AYES (In favour of the ban) Ainsworth, Mr. Peter Amess, Mr. David Ancram, rh Mr. Michael Bacon, Mr. Richard Baker, Norman Barrett, John Battle, rh John Bell, Sir Stuart Benton, Mr. Joe Benyon, Mr. Richard Binley, Mr. Brian Bone, Mr. Peter Borrow, Mr. David S. Brady, Mr. Graham Brazier, Mr. Julian Breed, Mr. Colin Brokenshire, James Browne, rh Des Burns, Mr. Simon Burrowes, Mr. David Burt, Alistair Byers, rh Mr. Stephen Cable, Dr. Vincent Campbell, Mr. Gregory Campbell, Mr. Ronnie Carmichael, Mr. Alistair Cash, Mr. William Challen, Colin Chapman, Ben Chope, Mr. Christopher Clarke, rh Mr. Tom Conway, Derek Cooper, Rosie Cormack, Sir Patrick Cox, Mr. Geoffrey Crausby, Mr. David Creagh, Mary Cruddas, Jon Cummings, John Cunningham, Mr. Jim Cunningham, Tony Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) Dodds, Mr. Nigel Dorries, Mrs. Nadine Drew, Mr. David Duddridge, James Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain Durkan, Mark Evennett, Mr. David Fallon, Mr. Michael Farron, Tim Field, rh Mr. Frank Field, Mr. Mark Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) Fox, Dr. Liam Francois, Mr. Mark Garnier, Mr. Edward Gibb, Mr. Nick Goggins, Paul Goodman, Mr. Paul Gove, Michael Grayling, Chris Green, Damian Grieve, Mr. Dominic Grogan, Mr. John Gummer, rh Mr. John Gwynne, Andrew Hague, rh Mr. William Hammond, Stephen Hanson, rh Mr. David Harper, Mr. Mark Hayes, Mr. John Heald, Mr. Oliver Hemming, John Hendrick, Mr. Mark Hermon, Lady Hillier, Meg Hoban, Mr. Mark Hoey, Kate Hollobone, Mr. Philip Holloway, Mr. Adam Hosie, Stewart Howarth, Mr. Gerald Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay Hunter, Mark Hurd, Mr. Nick Jackson, Mr. Stewart Jones, Mr. David Jones, Helen Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald Kelly, rh Ruth Khan, Mr. Sadiq Kilfoyle, Mr. Peter Knight, rh Mr. Greg Laing, Mrs. Eleanor Leigh, Mr. Edward Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian Lidington, Mr. David Luff, Peter Mackinlay, Andrew Maclean, rh David MacNeil, Mr. Angus Main, Anne Malins, Mr. Humfrey Marsden, Mr. Gordon Maude, rh Mr. Francis May, rh Mrs. Theresa McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas McCrea, Dr. William McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair McFall, rh John McGrady, Mr. Eddie McGuire, Mrs. Anne McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick Meale, Mr. Alan Milton, Anne Mudie, Mr. George Mulholland, Greg Murphy, Mr. Denis Murphy, Mr. Jim Murphy, rh Mr. Paul O'Brien, Mr. Mike Owen, Albert Paisley, rh Rev. Ian Paterson, Mr. Owen Pelling, Mr. Andrew Pickles, Mr. Eric Pope, Mr. Greg Pound, Stephen Prentice, Bridget Pritchard, Mark Pugh, Dr. John Randall, Mr. John Redwood, rh Mr. John Reed, Mr. Andy Reid, rh John Robertson, Hugh Robertson, Mr. Laurence Robinson, Mrs. Iris Rooney, Mr. Terry Rowen, Paul Roy, Mr. Frank Ruane, Chris Sarwar, Mr. Mohammad Scott, Mr. Lee Selous, Andrew Shepherd, Mr. Richard Simpson, Alan Simpson, David Singh, Mr. Marsha Smith, Geraldine Spelman, Mrs. Caroline Spring, Mr. Richard Stewart, Ian Streeter, Mr. Gary Stuart, Ms Gisela Swayne, Mr. Desmond Syms, Mr. Robert Taylor, Ms Dari Taylor, David Teather, Sarah Thurso, John Touhig, rh Mr. Don Trickett, Jon Turner, Mr. Andrew Twigg, Derek Vaz, rh Keith Walker, Mr. Charles Wareing, Mr. Robert N. Waterson, Mr. Nigel Watkinson, Angela Webb, Steve Weir, Mr. Mike Widdecombe, rh Miss Ann Younger-Ross, Richard Tellers for the Ayes: Daniel Kawczynski and Mr. Nigel Evans NOES (for animal / human hybrid embryos) Abbott, Ms Diane Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob Alexander, Danny Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas Allen, Mr. Graham Anderson, Mr. David Armstrong, rh Hilary Atkinson, Mr. Peter Austin, Mr. Ian Austin, John Bailey, Mr. Adrian Baldry, Tony Balls, rh Ed Banks, Gordon Barlow, Ms Celia Baron, Mr. John Barron, rh Mr. Kevin Bayley, Hugh Beckett, rh Margaret Begg, Miss Anne Bellingham, Mr. Henry Bercow, John Beresford, Sir Paul Berry, Roger Betts, Mr. Clive Blackman, Liz Blears, rh Hazel Blunkett, rh Mr. David Blunt, Mr. Crispin Boswell, Mr. Tim Bottomley, Peter Bradshaw, Mr. Ben Brake, Tom Brooke, Annette Brown, rh Mr. Gordon Brown, Lyn Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas Brown, Mr. Russell Browne, Mr. Jeremy Browning, Angela Bruce, rh Malcolm Bryant, Chris Buck, Ms Karen Burden, Richard Burnham, rh Andy Burstow, Mr. Paul Burt, Lorely Byrne, Mr. Liam Caborn, rh Mr. Richard Cameron, rh Mr. David Campbell, Mr. Alan Campbell, rh Sir Menzies Carswell, Mr. Douglas Cawsey, Mr. Ian Chaytor, Mr. David Clapham, Mr. Michael Clappison, Mr. James Clark, Greg Clark, Ms Katy Clark, Paul Clarke, rh Mr. Charles Clegg, rh Mr. Nick Clelland, Mr. David Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey Coffey, Ann Cohen, Harry Cooper, rh Yvette Cousins, Jim Curry, rh Mr. David Darling, rh Mr. Alistair Davey, Mr. Edward David, Mr. Wayne Davidson, Mr. Ian Davies, Mr. Quentin Dean, Mrs. Janet Denham, rh Mr. John Devine, Mr. Jim Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit Dismore, Mr. Andrew Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan Dobson, rh Frank Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. Doran, Mr. Frank Dowd, Jim Dunne, Mr. Philip Eagle, Angela Eagle, Maria Efford, Clive Ellman, Mrs. Louise Engel, Natascha Ennis, Jeff Featherstone, Lynne Fisher, Mark Fitzpatrick, Jim Flint, rh Caroline Flynn, Paul Follett, Barbara Foster, Mr. Don Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) Francis, Dr. Hywel Gapes, Mike Gauke, Mr. David George, Andrew Gerrard, Mr. Neil Gibson, Dr. Ian Gidley, Sandra Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl Gilroy, Linda Godsiff, Mr. Roger Goldsworthy, Julia Goodman, Helen Gray, Mr. James Greening, Justine Griffith, Nia Hain, rh Mr. Peter Hall, Mr. Mike Hall, Patrick Hamilton, Mr. Fabian Hancock, Mr. Mike Harman, rh Ms Harriet Harris, Dr. Evan Harris, Mr. Tom Harvey, Nick Havard, Mr. Dai Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David Hendry, Charles Hepburn, Mr. Stephen Herbert, Nick Hewitt, rh Ms Patricia Heyes, David Hill, rh Keith Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon Holmes, Paul Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey Hope, Phil Hopkins, Kelvin Horam, Mr. John Horwood, Martin Howard, rh Mr. Michael Howarth, David Howarth, rh Mr. George Howells, Dr. Kim Hughes, rh Beverley Huhne, Chris Humble, Mrs. Joan Hunt, Mr. Jeremy Hutton, rh Mr. John Iddon, Dr. Brian Illsley, Mr. Eric Ingram, rh Mr. Adam Irranca-Davies, Huw Jackson, Glenda Jackson, Mr. Stewart James, Mrs. Siân C. Jenkin, Mr. Bernard Johnson, rh Alan Johnson, Mr. Boris Johnson, Ms Diana R. Jones, Lynne Jones, Mr. Martyn Jowell, rh Tessa Keeble, Ms Sally Keeley, Barbara Keen, Ann Keetch, Mr. Paul Kemp, Mr. Fraser Kennedy, rh Jane Key, Robert Kidney, Mr. David Kirkbride, Miss Julie Knight, Jim Kramer, Susan Kumar, Dr. Ashok Ladyman, Dr. Stephen Lait, Mrs. Jacqui Lamb, Norman Lammy, Mr. David Lansley, Mr. Andrew Laws, Mr. David Lazarowicz, Mark Leech, Mr. John Lepper, David Levitt, Tom Lewis, Mr. Ivan Lewis, Dr. Julian Linton, Martin Lloyd, Tony Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn Love, Mr. Andrew Lucas, Ian Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew Mactaggart, Fiona Malik, Mr. Shahid Mallaber, Judy Mann, John Maples, Mr. John Marris, Rob Martlew, Mr. Eric Mates, rh Mr. Michael McCafferty, Chris McCarthy, Kerry McCarthy-Fry, Sarah McDonnell, John McFadden, Mr. Pat McIntosh, Miss Anne McIsaac, Shona McKechin, Ann McNulty, rh Mr. Tony Meacher, rh Mr. Michael Merron, Gillian Milburn, rh Mr. Alan Miliband, rh Edward Miller, Andrew Miller, Mrs. Maria Milton, Anne Moffatt, Laura Mole, Chris Moon, Mrs. Madeleine Moran, Margaret Morden, Jessica Morgan, Julie Mountford, Kali Mullin, Mr. Chris Munn, Meg Murrison, Dr. Andrew Naysmith, Dr. Doug Norris, Dan O'Hara, Mr. Edward Oaten, Mr. Mark Olner, Mr. Bill Öpik, Lembit Osborne, Mr. George Osborne, Sandra Ottaway, Richard Paice, Mr. James Palmer, Dr. Nick Pearson, Ian Penning, Mike Penrose, John Plaskitt, Mr. James Prentice, Mr. Gordon Prescott, rh Mr. John Primarolo, rh Dawn Prosser, Gwyn Purchase, Mr. Ken Purnell, rh James Rammell, Bill Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick Reed, Mr. Jamie Reid, Mr. Alan Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm Riordan, Mrs. Linda Robertson, Angus Robertson, John Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey Rogerson, Dan Ruddock, Joan Russell, Bob Salter, Martin Shapps, Grant Shaw, Jonathan Sheerman, Mr. Barry Sheridan, Jim Short, rh Clare Simmonds, Mark Simpson, Mr. Keith Skinner, Mr. Dennis Slaughter, Mr. Andy Smith, rh Mr. Andrew Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) Smith, rh Jacqui Smith, Sir Robert Snelgrove, Anne Soames, Mr. Nicholas Soulsby, Sir Peter Southworth, Helen Spellar, rh Mr. John Spicer, Sir Michael Stanley, rh Sir John Starkey, Dr. Phyllis Steen, Mr. Anthony Stoate, Dr. Howard Strang, rh Dr. Gavin Straw, rh Mr. Jack Stringer, Graham Stuart, Mr. Graham Stunell, Andrew Swinson, Jo Swire, Mr. Hugo Tami, Mark Taylor, Matthew Taylor, Dr. Richard Thomas, Mr. Gareth Thornberry, Emily Timms, rh Mr. Stephen Tipping, Paddy Todd, Mr. Mark Tredinnick, David Turner, Dr. Desmond Tyrie, Mr. Andrew Ussher, Kitty Vaizey, Mr. Edward Vara, Mr. Shailesh Viggers, Peter Villiers, Mrs. Theresa Vis, Dr. Rudi Walley, Joan Waltho, Lynda Ward, Claire Whitehead, Dr. Alan Wicks, Malcolm Wiggin, Bill Williams, rh Mr. Alan Williams, Mrs. Betty Williams, Hywel Williams, Mark Williams, Mr. Roger Williams, Stephen Willott, Jenny Wills, Mr. Michael Wilson, Phil Wilson, Mr. Rob Winnick, Mr. David Winterton, rh Ms Rosie Wishart, Pete Wood, Mike Woolas, Mr. Phil Wright, Mr. Anthony Wright, David Wright, Mr. Iain Wright, Jeremy Wright, Dr. Tony Wyatt, Derek Young, rh Sir George ... This is how the second vote went on banning full hybrids (50% human 50% animal embryos). Again it was lost, but was much closer. AYES (in favour of banning full hybrids) Ainsworth, Mr. Peter Amess, Mr. David Ancram, rh Mr. Michael Bacon, Mr. Richard Baker, Norman Baldry, Tony Baron, Mr. John Barrett, John Battle, rh John Bell, Sir Stuart Bellingham, Mr. Henry Benton, Mr. Joe Benyon, Mr. Richard Binley, Mr. Brian Bone, Mr. Peter Borrow, Mr. David S. Boswell, Mr. Tim Brady, Mr. Graham Brazier, Mr. Julian Breed, Mr. Colin Brokenshire, James Brooke, Annette Browne, rh Des Burns, Mr. Simon Burrowes, Mr. David Burt, Alistair Burt, Lorely Byers, rh Mr. Stephen Cable, Dr. Vincent Campbell, Mr. Gregory Campbell, Mr. Ronnie Carmichael, Mr. Alistair Cash, Mr. William Chapman, Ben Chope, Mr. Christopher Clark, Greg Clarke, rh Mr. Tom Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey Conway, Derek Cooper, Rosie Cormack, Sir Patrick Cox, Mr. Geoffrey Crausby, Mr. David Creagh, Mary Cruddas, Jon Cummings, John Cunningham, Mr. Jim Cunningham, Tony Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) Dodds, Mr. Nigel Dorries, Mrs. Nadine Drew, Mr. David Duddridge, James Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain Durkan, Mark Evans, Mr. Nigel Evennett, Mr. David Fallon, Mr. Michael Farron, Tim Field, rh Mr. Frank Field, Mr. Mark Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) Fox, Dr. Liam Francois, Mr. Mark Garnier, Mr. Edward Gibb, Mr. Nick Gidley, Sandra Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl Goggins, Paul Goodman, Mr. Paul Gove, Michael Grayling, Chris Green, Damian Grieve, Mr. Dominic Grogan, Mr. John Gummer, rh Mr. John Gwynne, Andrew Hague, rh Mr. William Hammond, Mr. Philip Hammond, Stephen Hancock, Mr. Mike Hanson, rh Mr. David Harper, Mr. Mark Hayes, Mr. John Heald, Mr. Oliver Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David Hemming, John Hendry, Charles Herbert, Nick Hermon, Lady Hillier, Meg Hoban, Mr. Mark Hoey, Kate Hollobone, Mr. Philip Holloway, Mr. Adam Horam, Mr. John Hosie, Stewart Howard, rh Mr. Michael Howarth, Mr. Gerald Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay Hunt, Mr. Jeremy Hunter, Mark Hurd, Mr. Nick Irranca-Davies, Huw Jackson, Mr. Stewart Jones, Mr. David Jones, Helen Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald Kawczynski, Daniel Kelly, rh Ruth Khan, Mr. Sadiq Kidney, Mr. David Kilfoyle, Mr. Peter Knight, rh Mr. Greg Laing, Mrs. Eleanor Lansley, Mr. Andrew Leigh, Mr. Edward Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian Lidington, Mr. David Loughton, Tim Luff, Peter Mackinlay, Andrew Maclean, rh David MacNeil, Mr. Angus Main, Anne Malins, Mr. Humfrey Marsden, Mr. Gordon Maude, rh Mr. Francis McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas McCrea, Dr. William McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair McFall, rh John McGrady, Mr. Eddie McGuire, Mrs. Anne McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick Meale, Mr. Alan Miller, Mrs. Maria Milton, Anne Mudie, Mr. George Mulholland, Greg Murphy, Mr. Denis Murphy, Mr. Jim Murphy, rh Mr. Paul Murrison, Dr. Andrew O'Brien, Mr. Mike O'Brien, Mr. Stephen Ottaway, Richard Owen, Albert Paice, Mr. James Paisley, rh Rev. Ian Paterson, Mr. Owen Pelling, Mr. Andrew Penning, Mike Pickles, Mr. Eric Pope, Mr. Greg Pound, Stephen Prentice, Bridget Prisk, Mr. Mark Pugh, Dr. John Randall, Mr. John Redwood, rh Mr. John Reed, Mr. Andy Reid, Mr. Alan Reid, rh John Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm Robertson, Hugh Robertson, Mr. Laurence Robinson, Mrs. Iris Rogerson, Dan Rooney, Mr. Terry Rowen, Paul Roy, Mr. Frank Ruane, Chris Russell, Bob Sarwar, Mr. Mohammad Scott, Mr. Lee Selous, Andrew Shepherd, Mr. Richard Simmonds, Mark Simpson, Alan Simpson, David Singh, Mr. Marsha Smith, Geraldine Soames, Mr. Nicholas Spelman, Mrs. Caroline Spicer, Sir Michael Spring, Mr. Richard Stanley, rh Sir John Steen, Mr. Anthony Stewart, Ian Streeter, Mr. Gary Stuart, Ms Gisela Stuart, Mr. Graham Stunell, Andrew Swayne, Mr. Desmond Swinson, Jo Swire, Mr. Hugo Syms, Mr. Robert Taylor, Ms Dari Taylor, David Teather, Sarah Thurso, John Touhig, rh Mr. Don Trickett, Jon Turner, Mr. Andrew Twigg, Derek Vaizey, Mr. Edward Vara, Mr. Shailesh Vaz, rh Keith Viggers, Peter Walker, Mr. Charles Wallace, Mr. Ben Wareing, Mr. Robert N. Waterson, Mr. Nigel Watkinson, Angela Webb, Steve Weir, Mr. Mike Williams, Mark Williams, Mr. Roger Wilson, Mr. Rob Wood, Mike Wright, Jeremy Younger-Ross, Richard Tellers for the Ayes: Mark Pritchard and Miss Ann Widdecombe NOES - (In favour of allowing full hybrds embryos to be created) Abbott, Ms Diane Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob Alexander, Danny Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas Allen, Mr. Graham Anderson, Mr. David Armstrong, rh Hilary Atkinson, Mr. Peter Austin, Mr. Ian Austin, John Bailey, Mr. Adrian Balls, rh Ed Banks, Gordon Barlow, Ms Celia Barron, rh Mr. Kevin Bayley, Hugh Beckett, rh Margaret Begg, Miss Anne Bercow, John Beresford, Sir Paul Berry, Roger Betts, Mr. Clive Blackman, Liz Blears, rh Hazel Blunkett, rh Mr. David Blunt, Mr. Crispin Bradshaw, Mr. Ben Brake, Tom Brennan, Kevin Brown, rh Mr. Gordon Brown, Lyn Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas Brown, Mr. Russell Browne, Mr. Jeremy Bruce, rh Malcolm Bryant, Chris Buck, Ms Karen Burden, Richard Burnham, rh Andy Burstow, Mr. Paul Butler, Ms Dawn Byrne, Mr. Liam Caborn, rh Mr. Richard Campbell, Mr. Alan Campbell, rh Sir Menzies Carswell, Mr. Douglas Cawsey, Mr. Ian Chaytor, Mr. David Clapham, Mr. Michael Clappison, Mr. James Clark, Ms Katy Clark, Paul Clarke, rh Mr. Charles Clegg, rh Mr. Nick Clelland, Mr. David Coffey, Ann Cohen, Harry Cooper, rh Yvette Corbyn, Jeremy Cousins, Jim Cryer, Mrs. Ann Curry, rh Mr. David Darling, rh Mr. Alistair Davey, Mr. Edward David, Mr. Wayne Davidson, Mr. Ian Davies, Mr. Quentin Dean, Mrs. Janet Denham, rh Mr. John Devine, Mr. Jim Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit Dismore, Mr. Andrew Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan Dobson, rh Frank Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. Doran, Mr. Frank Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen Dowd, Jim Dunne, Mr. Philip Eagle, Angela Eagle, Maria Efford, Clive Ellman, Mrs. Louise Engel, Natascha Ennis, Jeff Featherstone, Lynne Fisher, Mark Fitzpatrick, Jim Flint, rh Caroline Flynn, Paul Follett, Barbara Foster, Mr. Don Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) Francis, Dr. Hywel Gapes, Mike Gauke, Mr. David George, Andrew Gerrard, Mr. Neil Gibson, Dr. Ian Gilroy, Linda Godsiff, Mr. Roger Goldsworthy, Julia Goodman, Helen Gray, Mr. James Greening, Justine Griffith, Nia Hain, rh Mr. Peter Hall, Mr. Mike Hall, Patrick Hamilton, Mr. Fabian Harman, rh Ms Harriet Harris, Dr. Evan Harris, Mr. Tom Harvey, Nick Havard, Mr. Dai Hepburn, Mr. Stephen Hewitt, rh Ms Patricia Heyes, David Hill, rh Keith Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon Holmes, Paul Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey Hope, Phil Hopkins, Kelvin Horwood, Martin Howarth, David Howarth, rh Mr. George Howells, Dr. Kim Hughes, rh Beverley Huhne, Chris Humble, Mrs. Joan Hutton, rh Mr. John Iddon, Dr. Brian Illsley, Mr. Eric Ingram, rh Mr. Adam Jackson, Glenda James, Mrs. Siân C. Jenkin, Mr. Bernard Johnson, rh Alan Johnson, Ms Diana R. Jones, Lynne Jones, Mr. Martyn Jowell, rh Tessa Keeble, Ms Sally Keeley, Barbara Keen, Ann Keetch, Mr. Paul Kemp, Mr. Fraser Kennedy, rh Jane Key, Robert Kirkbride, Miss Julie Knight, Jim Kramer, Susan Kumar, Dr. Ashok Ladyman, Dr. Stephen Lait, Mrs. Jacqui Lamb, Norman Lammy, Mr. David Laws, Mr. David Lazarowicz, Mark Leech, Mr. John Lepper, David Levitt, Tom Lewis, Mr. Ivan Lewis, Dr. Julian Linton, Martin Lloyd, Tony Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn Love, Mr. Andrew Lucas, Ian Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew Mactaggart, Fiona Malik, Mr. Shahid Mallaber, Judy Mann, John Marris, Rob Martlew, Mr. Eric Mates, rh Mr. Michael McCafferty, Chris McCarthy, Kerry McCarthy-Fry, Sarah McDonnell, John McFadden, Mr. Pat McIntosh, Miss Anne McIsaac, Shona McKechin, Ann McNulty, rh Mr. Tony Meacher, rh Mr. Michael Merron, Gillian Milburn, rh Mr. Alan Miliband, rh Edward Miller, Andrew Moffatt, Laura Mole, Chris Moon, Mrs. Madeleine Moran, Margaret Morden, Jessica Morgan, Julie Mountford, Kali Mullin, Mr. Chris Munn, Meg Naysmith, Dr. Doug Norris, Dan O'Hara, Mr. Edward Oaten, Mr. Mark Olner, Mr. Bill Öpik, Lembit Osborne, Mr. George Osborne, Sandra Palmer, Dr. Nick Pearson, Ian Penrose, John Plaskitt, Mr. James Prentice, Mr. Gordon Prescott, rh Mr. John Primarolo, rh Dawn Prosser, Gwyn Purchase, Mr. Ken Purnell, rh James Rammell, Bill Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick Reed, Mr. Jamie Riordan, Mrs. Linda Robertson, Angus Robertson, John Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey Ruddock, Joan Salter, Martin Shapps, Grant Shaw, Jonathan Sheerman, Mr. Barry Sheridan, Jim Short, rh Clare Simpson, Mr. Keith Skinner, Mr. Dennis Slaughter, Mr. Andy Smith, rh Mr. Andrew Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) Smith, rh Jacqui Smith, Sir Robert Snelgrove, Anne Soulsby, Sir Peter Southworth, Helen Spellar, rh Mr. John Starkey, Dr. Phyllis Stoate, Dr. Howard Strang, rh Dr. Gavin Straw, rh Mr. Jack Stringer, Graham Tami, Mark Taylor, Matthew Taylor, Dr. Richard Thomas, Mr. Gareth Thornberry, Emily Timms, rh Mr. Stephen Tipping, Paddy Todd, Mr. Mark Turner, Dr. Desmond Tyrie, Mr. Andrew Ussher, Kitty Villiers, Mrs. Theresa Vis, Dr. Rudi Walley, Joan Waltho, Lynda Ward, Claire Whitehead, Dr. Alan Wicks, Malcolm Wiggin, Bill Williams, rh Mr. Alan Williams, Mrs. Betty Williams, Hywel Williams, Stephen Willott, Jenny Wills, Mr. Michael Wilson, Phil Winnick, Mr. David Winterton, rh Ms Rosie Wishart, Pete Woolas, Mr. Phil Wright, Mr. Anthony Wright, David Wright, Mr. Iain Wright, Dr. Tony Wyatt, Derek Young, rh Sir George Tellers for the Noes: Alison Seabeck and Mr. Bob Blizzard |
|
| Last Updated ( Wednesday, 16 July 2008 11:48 ) | |
